Categorized | Feature, Prostate Treatment

Saturation Biopsy Detects More Cancers

According to a new report, analysis of 20 to 24 biopsy cores is superior to analysis of 12 to 14 cores for detecting prostate cancer in men who’ve had a normal prostate biopsy in the past.

J. Stephen Jones, M.D., from Cleveland Clinic, Ohio said, “We have shown that transrectal saturation biopsy is as easy and safe to perform as standard biopsy while detecting almost 1/3 more cancers. With these findings, we are confident that this approach offers benefit with negligible downside.”

Jones did however caution that it would be premature to suggest that this should be made universal for a number of reasons.  First, this has only been shown in one study.  Second, this must be balanced against the potential to detect clinically insignificant cancers that we might be better not knowing about even though saturation biopsy detected almost a third more cancers and had equivalence complication rates.

Jones and colleagues compared the results of extended and saturation prostate biopsy protocols in a first repeat prostate biopsy population of 1056 men (393 with a 12 to 14-core extended biopsy and 663 with a 20 to 24-core saturation biopsy.  The authors reported their findings in the Journal of Urology. The detection rate was significantly higher in the saturation biopsy group than in the extended biopsy group.  Over a third of the positive biopsies (37.8%), however, met predetermined criteria for clinical insignificance, and there was a trend toward increased detection of clinically insignificant cancer in saturation compared to extended biopsies (40.1 percent compared to 32.6 percent).

For higher-risk populations, detection rates were higher for saturation biopsy than for extended biopsy, but the differences did not reach statistical significance.  The increased detection with saturation biopsy was significant for men whose initial biopsy was completely normal.

Comments are closed.

 

January 2012
M T W T F S S
« Dec   Feb »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031